Journal Article 1 Mention
Strategies to Reduce the Environmental Lifetimes of Drinking Straws in the Coastal Ocean
Bryan D. James•2024
Yanchen SunMounir Izallalen
Top 13% · 87th Percentile
24 citations · Pollution
Open Access

TLDR

Some straw materials broke down in coastal seawater within months, while others showed no measurable change. Making a biodegradable straw porous sped its breakdown, so both its material and shape matter.

Summary

1 Study Aim

The authors aimed to estimate how long commercial drinking straws persist in coastal seawater, identify the microorganisms living on them, and test whether changing straw shape could speed breakdown. They compared cellulose diacetate (CDA, a cellulose-based plastic), polyhydroxyalkanoate (PHA, a plastic made by microorganisms), paper, polylactic acid (PLA, a plant-derived plastic), and polypropylene (PP, a conventional plastic). The study asked which straws break down in seawater and whether a different design can make them break down faster.

2 Study Design

The researchers incubated commercial straw samples and a prototype porous CDA straw in a flow-through seawater mesocosm (a controlled tank system supplied with seawater) for 16 weeks at 20 °C. They measured mass loss, using it to estimate breakdown rates and projected environmental lifetimes. Each straw type had three replicates at each measurement time. They also analyzed microbial communities from straw surfaces using 16S ribosomal RNA (rRNA) gene sequencing, which identifies bacteria by their genetic material. The seawater came from one location, and the setup excluded sunlight and physical wear. They tested several straw types in a seawater tank and tracked changes in their mass and surface microbes.

3 Findings

CDA, PHA, and paper straws lost 25–50% of their mass over 16 weeks; projected lifetimes were 20 ± 4 months for solid CDA, 15 ± 1 months for each PHA straw, and 10 ± 1 and 13 ± 2 months for uncoated and coated paper. PLA and PP showed no measurable mass loss. Porous CDA lost 29% more mass than solid CDA and had a degradation rate 184% higher; its projected lifetime was about 8 months. Communities on materials that degraded differed by material, while PLA and PP hosted similar communities. The authors recommend designing for both breakdown and function, while noting that conditions vary beyond this single-temperature, single-location test. Some straws broke down within months, and making one more porous shortened its estimated lifetime.

Abstract

Degradability in natural environments is a growing design requirement for consumer plastics. However, data on their biodegradation rates and environmental lifetimes in the coastal ocean are lacking, limiting informed engineering and regulatory decisions. Single-use drinking straws, a common marine litter relevant to key stakeholders, exemplify this. To fill this knowledge gap, commercial drinking straws made of cellulose diacetate (CDA), polyhydroxyalkanoates (PHA), paper, polylactic acid (PLA), and polypropylene (PP) were incubated for 16 weeks in a flow-through seawater mesocosm and monitored for degradation and microbial community composition. CDA, PHA, and paper straws reduced in mass by up to 50%, projecting environmental lifetimes of 7-15 months in the coastal ocean. PP and PLA showed no measurable mass loss. Lifetimes depended on the material and dimensions of the straw, demonstrating the need to balance function and degradation properties. The materials that biodegraded exhibited unique microbial communities driven by chemical structure, whereas those materials that were persistent exhibited similar communities despite substantial differences in chemical structure. To reduce the persistence of drinking straws, we hypothesized that changing product form (i.e., surface area), not just material, can reduce their environmental lifetimes. To test our hypothesis, we evaluated the biodegradation of a prototype foamed CDA straw. Its specific surface degradation rate was 190% faster than its solid counterpart, resulting in a shorter projected environmental lifetime than the paper straws. Our findings provide the initial constraints of the environmental lifetimes of several commercial drinking straws and identify strategies to design next-generation bioplastic consumer products with reduced persistence.

Referenced In