Claim: Arabs “Don’t Win” the Nobel Prize, Fields Prize or Wolf Prize

Verdict: False and misleading

“There's 500 million Arabs in the world, and yet they don't produce science. They don't win the Nobel Prize, they don't win the Fields Prize, they don't win the Wolf prize. They don't produce literature”

– RFK Jr.

Robert F Kennedy Jr. says Arabs don’t produce science or literature

RFK Jr. took to the stage at a republican campaign event this week and used his time in the spotlight to claim that Arabs – that is, the huge number of people falling into this ethnic and linguistic group – make no substantial contribution to science.

Most of the response to these comments has focused on the inherent prejudice many people see in his comments. But putting that aside for a moment: is it even true?  

The Most Recent Counter-Example

To evaluate his claim, all that’s needed is a brief look at past Nobel Prize winners. While AP’s “Fact Check” [2] covered many examples, a lot of these are Peace Prize winners, which doesn’t really address the meat of Kennedy’s claim. He is talking about science. So how far do we have to go back to find a solid counter-example?

Only to the 2025 Nobel Prize in Chemistry. Palestinian-Jordanian chemist Omar Yaghi won the prize along with two other researchers for his work on metal-organic frameworks. These are molecular structures, designed so there are multiple cavities inside a crystalline framework, which can be used to store specific substances. Moreover, Yaghi won the Wolf Prize in 2018 for the same work.

Older Examples

And Yaghi isn’t the only one. Ardem Patapoutian, a Lebanese-Armenian raised in Beirut, won the Medicine Prize in 2021 for discovering the receptors for temperature and touch. And Ahmed Zewail, an Egyptian-American (raised in Egypt) won the 1999 Chemistry Prize for his work with femtosecond spectroscopy.

The Grain of Truth – and the Nature of the Falsehood

There is a grain of truth in RFK Jr.’s statement, but a small one: nobody seems to have won the Fields Medal with citizenship in an Arab-majority country.

But searching for counter-examples almost misses the point. Think about this: did RFK Jr. look at the facts before making this statement? Clearly not. And he went even further with his claims. Why suggest Arabs don’t “produce science” or “produce literature”? There are not many reasons someone would make much an absurd statement. I’ll leave it to the reader to choose the most appropriate.  

From [3]. Omar Yaghi, a Palestinian-Jordanian chemist, shared the 2025 Nobel Prize in Chemistry for constructing this material, which has cubic spaces to hold a lot of material. According to the caption, just a couple of grams can hold an area as big as a football pitch.
4 20
StarTalk Show Notes•15 days ago
StarTalkexoplanets

Season 17, Episode 66: How Do We Know There’s One Planet Per Star on Average?

Hey StarTalkians! Season 17, episode 66 was an exoplanet-focused discussion between Neil, co-host Matt and guest Professor Evgenya Shkolnik. Early in the discussion, they discuss a fact that comes up on StarTalk a lot: that each star has at least one planet, on average.

The Habitable Worlds Observatory with Evgenya Shkolnik - StarTalk Radio

(from 4:50)

Professor Shkolnik explains how we know this briefly, but what data exactly leads to this conclusion?

The First Exoplanets We Detected

Before getting into how we came to the estimate, it’s worth looking at the early hunt for exoplanets. The first confirmed discovery came in a 1992 paper, which looked at data from a pulsar, a rapidly-rotating type of star which produces a reliable, periodic signal pulse. This particular pulsar – the not-so-memorably named PSR1257+12 – should release a pulse every 6.2 milliseconds. However, precise measurement showed an unexpected, periodic variation in timing.

Researchers realised that this was likely due to a planet. As the pulsar is tugged slightly due to planetary orbits, the pulses’ travel time to Earth varied. In fact, they determined two exoplanets were probably responsible.

A similar but more broadly-applicable method is using the same effect of planetary orbits on a more regular star. The change in star motion relative to Earth, as it’s gravitationally pulled by an exoplanet, produces a Doppler shift in the wavelength – like the apparent change in pitch as an ambulance speeds past you. The first exoplanet discovery in a main-sequence star came in 1995 using this method.

Why It’s One Planet Per Star on Average

But these are just two methods – there are many more. One of the most interesting is gravitational microlensing – the same method that will be used by the Nancy Grace Roman space telescope – which depends on the magnifying effect of small-scale gravitational lensing.

The likely source of the “one planet per star” claim is a 2012 paper which used microlensing data from two surveys, the Optical Gravitational Lensing Experiment (OGLE) and the Probing Lensing Anomalies Network (PLANET), from 2002 to 2007. As Professor Shkolnik explained, the researchers combined detections – matched across both datasets – with calculations of detection efficiency to make the estimate.

They found that in the range of between 0.5 to 10 Earth orbital distances and between 5 Earth masses and 10 Jupiter masses, every star in the Milky Way has 1.6 planets on average. They write “Planets around stars in our Galaxy thus seem to be the rule rather than the exception.”

The pulsar data from [2] that led to the first confirmed exoplanet. The solid line shows predictions of the variation if there are two exoplanets, and it matches the data points (dots) extremely well.
3 22

Join the social media for nerds.

Where sources matter.

By continuing with Apple or Google, you agree to the Terms of Service and Community Guidelines and you've read the Privacy Policy, including how Citation Check uses third-party AI services.

Have an account?

Mercedes C.•11 days ago
Anythingice cream

Adding protein to ice cream makes it melt slower?? 🍦🍧🍨🧁

Was recently rewatching Culinary Class Wars (S1 E4), and one of the contestants was eliminated - his ice cream dish was critiqued to be a little 'off'.

He explained that he tweaked the recipe to incorporate a higher protein content (more eggs) in fear that the ice cream would melt too fast during the judging process. The judges also seemed quite clear on what went down as well - so that got me thinking is this common knowledge among chefs? ∘ ∘ ∘ ( °ヮ° ) ?

🧪 A quick search on Google led me to quite the scientific exploration of the process and chemistry of ice cream melting.

The Science of Ice Cream Meltdown and Structural Collapse: A Comprehensive Review

Proteins in ice cream not only contribute to its nutritional value but also play a key role in stabilizing the air–water (A/W) and oil‐water (O/W) interfaces, thereby influencing fat destabilization. The thickness of protein coverage on the O/W interface, the ability of the proteins to reduce interfacial tension, and the extent of surface coverage all play crucial roles in determining the degree of partial coalescence under the influence of shear forces during freezing. In the realm of dairy ice cream, whey protein and casein are the primary proteins influencing fat stabilization.

Notably, ice cream containing 10% protein forms an exceptionally stable emulsion, with no observed fat destabilization. 💪

Though I couldn't really find anything pertaining to egg proteins in particular --

Comprehensive Reviews in Food Science and Food Safety
Comprehensive Reviews in Food Science and Food Safety · 2025

The Science of Ice Cream Meltdown and Structural Collapse: A Comprehensive Review

Wu, Atik et al.
1 9
Jordie Li•11 days ago

Does mouth taping actually help you sleep?

There’s some evidence it can!

A 2025 study reviewed 10 studies on mouth tape, mouth seals, and chinstraps. Some studies found less snoring and fewer breathing pauses during sleep – especially in people with mild sleep apnoea.

The catch: the studies were small and most participants were sleep-clinic patients (not everyday sleepers). Importantly (and perhaps obviously) taping your mouth can be risky if you can’t breathe well through your nose.

So it might be worth a try, but if your nose is blocked (even from a cold), skip it!

PLoS ONE
PLoS ONE · 2025

Breaking social media fads and uncovering the safety and efficacy of mouth taping in patients with mouth breathing, sleep disordered breathing, or obstructive sleep apnea: A systematic review

Rhee, Iansavitchene et al.
1 21
RC Yu•11 days ago

Could the shingles vaccine lower dementia risk?

In Wales, people born on or after 2 September 1933 could get the shingles vaccine – but people born just a day earlier couldn't.

That cutoff created a rare natural experiment: two groups almost identical in age, but with different vaccination rates.

Remarkably, people who got the vaccine were 20% less likely to be diagnosed with dementia over the next 7 years. The effect was stronger in women.

Researchers aren’t sure why yet, but have some ideas. Check out the study for yourself!

Nature
Top 1% in Epidemiology
Nature · 2025

A natural experiment on the effect of herpes zoster vaccination on dementia

Eyting, Xie et al.
2 2

Can a pet help keep your mind sharp?

It might, especially if you live alone.

A UK study followed 8,000 adults (aged 50+) for 8 years.

Among people living alone, pet owners showed significantly slower decline in memory and verbal fluency. In fact, they kept pace with people who lived with other humans.

So, for someone living on their own – get a pet!

JAMA Network Open
Top 5% in Animal Science and Zoology
JAMA Network Open · 2023

Pet Ownership, Living Alone, and Cognitive Decline Among Adults 50 Years and Older

Li, Wang et al.
1 1
Mercedes C.•25 days ago
Anythingtyphoon

Typhoons in Taiwan 🌪️

After the intense Typhoon Champi, everything finally seems to be returning to normal as of Sunday. Phew - This one was really no joking matter. 💨

Hope everyone is doing fine. Though I have heard some quote unquote "trends", on typhoons from Taiwanese locals that I made me do a quick search.

。𖦹°‧ Some have pretty good scientific backing behind them that I thought it would be interesting to share :

  1. Typhoons that come after the summer months (June/July/Aug/Sept) tend to be bigger and more dangerous.

Interestingly, there is quite a bit of evidence behind this. A 2025 paper outlines the mechanism and mentions that in autumn, typhoons travel more equatorward and encounter more favourable ocean sub-surface conditions for intensification. Compared to summer, the thermodynamic disequilibrium between the ocean surface and the lower atmosphere is more prominent.

  1. In recent years, the Typhoons have been coming later in the year than before.

There seems to be a dispute over this as:

A 2023 paper identifies a significant seasonal advance of intense typhoons since the 1980s in most tropical oceans, with earlier-shifting rates of 3.7 and 3.2 days per decade for the Northern and Southern Hemispheres, respectively.

Another 2025 paper finds a significant delay of the typhoon season in China, shifting later at a rate of 5 to 8 days per decade over the satellite era 1979−2023. 

∘ ∘ ∘ ( °ヮ° ) ?

👀 We know that El Niño plays a big role in typhoons. And given the Super El Niño this year with all the Indonesian forest fires, I guess its not a surprise that this year’s typhoons are also stronger it's a grim outlook. I guess my only other questions is: how much did global warming play a role in this? or are they more independent climate change? 🌧️

3 5
StarTalk Show Notes•10 hours ago
StarTalkmercury

Season 17, Episode 69: Why is it So Hard to Land on Mercury?

Hey StarTalkians! Season 17, Episode 69 was a live-recorded episode celebrating cool space facts, with Neil, Paul, StarTalk producer Lindsey Walker and astrophysicist Charles Liu. Among many excellent factoids, the fact Lindsey mentions really struck me too:

Facts for Navigating the Universe with Charles Liu - StarTalk Radio

(from 27:55)

It is more fuel-efficient to completely exit the solar system than to land on the surface of Mercury. The fact shocked me at first, but if you think about the major steps in the process, it becomes almost obvious.

Step 1 (Kind Of): The Hohmann Transfer

Ignoring the whole “completely leaving the surface of the Earth” issue – which is needed wherever we’re going –  the “first” step is getting from Earth’s general orbital radius to Mercury’s.

This is done via a Hohmann transfer orbit. This is an orbital path around the sun that connects the loops of our orbit and the target planet’s. Rather than using fuel for the whole journey, you just need to use enough to nudge the craft into the right orbit around the sun.

An old NASA paper goes through this calculation for Mercury. This type of information is conveyed using the “delta v” (i.e. change in velocity) needed to get to the target – basically, how quickly we’d have to move the craft with propulsion or other tricks. For a simple Hohmann transfer “flyby,” this would be 4.8 km/s. As discussed on the podcast, with the increased gravity from the sun, slowing down is a big part of the challenge for this leg of the journey.

For reference, it takes about 8.7 km/s of delta-v to get out of the solar system.

Step 2: Earth’s Velocity to Mercury’s Velocity

And this is only the beginning. Mercury is much faster than Earth (47.4 vs. 29.8 km/s), so to actually get into orbit alongside it, we’ll need some more delta-v. This increases the requirement to 12.9 km/s [3], well beyond what you’d need to exit the solar system.

Step 3: Actually Landing

Actually landing on the surface takes this way further and makes the fact seem inevitable. Since Mercury has no atmosphere, landing without crashing requires a lot of thrust, as they pointed out on the podcast.

How BepiColombo is Doing It

The flight plan for BepiColombo (see image) alone shows how difficult visiting Mercury is. To minimize the delta-v, scientists use multiple gravity assists from planets, low-energy Lagrange points and more.

From Wikipedia (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Delta-v_budget). An excellent - if a little confusing - visualisation of the delta-v required to get to various places in the solar system.
0 1
Lee Johnson•3 days ago
Pop Culturehouse md

House, Grey’s Anatomy and the “Toxic Lady”

In season 8, episode 20 of House, MD, a pathologist performing an autopsy on a young woman suddenly cuts into his own head with the scalpel, and starts complaining about being cold. In Grey’s Anatomy, season 3 episode 14, a cancer patient’s herbal supplement interacts with her chemotherapy treatment and causes her to develop “toxic blood,” which knocks out several doctors.

Both of these stories are inspired by the same real case: the death of Gloria Ramirez in 1994.

These shows tend to take some liberties with the details. But the real story is interesting enough to have been published in peer-reviewed journals.

The Story of Gloria Ramirez

In mid-February 1994, a young woman with cervical cancer was brought a California emergency room. She was awake, but her breathing was rapid and shallow, her heart was beating too quickly to be effective and her blood pressure was declining.

After she didn’t respond to normal treatment, they opted to defibrillate. Several people noticed an oily sheen on her body, and a fruity, garlicky odour from her mouth. A nurse, Susan Kane, drew some blood, and noted a chemical smell to the blood, passing the sample to a respiratory therapist, Maureen Welch, who described it as ammonia-like. Welch passed the syringe to resident Julie Gorchynski, who noticed some yellow-brown crystals in the liquid.

One by one, they began to feel ill. Kane fainted and said her face was burning. Gorchynski felt queasy, passed out and developed apnea. Finally, Welch passed out too. Ramirez would eventually die.

The Speculative (But Best) Explanation

The case baffled investigators and was initially dismissed as mass hysteria. However, a better – if not perfect – explanation was developed and later published in Forensic Science International. The theory goes that Ramirez was using a dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) containing topical, possibly as a treatment for her cancer. This matches with the oily appearance of her skin, and the fruity, garlic-like odour from her mouth. The chemical was detected in her blood and bile.

Combined with the oxygen – given in the ambulance and afterwards – the DMSO may have converted to DMSO(2), which can form crystals in a solution, like those observed in her blood. This could then form into dimethyl sulfate DMSO(4), a toxic gas that causes symptoms much like those experienced by ER staff. This last step is the most scientifically suspect, but it is still the most scientific explanation that has been proposed.  

From [4]. The analysis of Gloria Ramirez's blood sample, showing a relative of the suspect chemical, dimethyl sulfone. The analysis also shows the presence of several painkillers.
0 4
Carol Euyang•23 days ago

This surprised me.

Paper straws worse for the environment than plastic, South Korea study finds | South China Morning Post Paper straws worse for the environment than plastic, South Korea study finds

SSouth China Morning Post · Oct 23, 2026

Paper straws worse for the environment than plastic, South Korea study finds

The report finds paper and bio-based straws generate higher life-cycle emissions, prompting calls to cut single-use consumption at source.

By Person, SCMP’s Asia desk, https://www.scmp.com/author/scmps-asia-desk
1 4