Claim: There is No Study Showing that Children Were Protected by the COVID Vaccine

Verdict: False and misleading

“Do you think that the COVID vaccine protected children? [...] Can you show me one study ... that shows that children were protected by the COVID vaccine? [...] that it did more good than harm to children. Can you show me one study that shows that?”

RFK talks vaccines, measles in interview with CNN's Dana Bash – RFK Jr. (from 7:25)

In his recent interview with CNN, RFK Jr. implicitly claimed – via a series of pointed, “gotcha” questions – that there were no studies showing that the COVID-19 vaccine protected children. Explicitly asking about proof “it did more good than harm,” he argued that there is no overall benefit to vaccinating children.

Is he right?

There is Plenty of Evidence that the COVID Vaccine Protects Children

RFK Jr. is absolutely incorrect to imply that no such evidence exists. While most people cannot pull a citation out of their heads on command, that isn’t the same as showing no evidence exists.

A systematic review of such studies was published in JAMA Pediatrics in 2023. It includes data from 15 observational studies and 2 randomized controlled trials focusing on children aged 5 to 11. The total number of participants was almost 11 million vaccinated and over 2.6 million unvaccinated children.

Among other things, this study found a lower risk of any COVID infection (53% reduction), symptomatic COVID infection (47% reduction), hospitalisations due to COVID-related illnesses (68% reduction) and multisystem inflammatory syndrome in children (95% reduction). It also found a 92% increase in the risk of adverse events, but only a non-significant increase in the risk of adverse events that prevent normal daily activities. 

What He Might Have Meant: The Risk of Myocarditis

This study did find the well-known risk of myocarditis following vaccination in younger people. However, this amounted to 1.3 cases per million after a first dose and 1.8 per million after a second dose.

Of course, this is not something to discount because of low incidence: it’s a legitimate concern.

However, this risk has to be compared to the risks following COVID infection, which is less likely in vaccinated children. A study from the UK found that there was an increased risk of myocarditis or pericarditis in the first 6 months after vaccination (in young people aged between 5 and 18), but noted that the risk is even higher after COVID infection.

Even without considering other risks (see images), it’s clear that the COVID vaccine is safer than COVID itself, even for myocarditis in young people.