Journal Article 2 Mentions
The influence of different forms of early childcare on children's emotional and behavioural development at school entry
Alan L. Stein•2012
Lars‐Erik MalmbergPenelope Leach
Top 2% · 98th Percentile
69 citations · Education

TLDR

Children’s emotional and behavior difficulties were more closely linked to family circumstances and care at home than to childcare outside the home. More time in group childcare was linked to more behavior difficulties, especially being overly active.

Summary

1 Study Aim

The authors aimed to examine how different kinds and amounts of childcare relate to children’s emotional and behavioral development near school entry. They focused on whether care outside the home was linked to children’s outcomes. The study asked whether children’s development was connected to the care they received before starting school.

2 Study Design

The researchers followed 991 families in England, first recruited when their children were 3 months old, and assessed them at 51 months. This longitudinal study (one that follows the same people over time) used questionnaires completed by mothers and teachers to assess children’s emotional and behavioral functioning. Researchers also repeatedly observed maternal caregiving (how mothers cared for their children), the quality of care from others, and time spent in different care settings. Researchers tracked families over time and compared children’s development with the care they received.

3 Findings

The study found that family factors had the strongest and most consistent links with children’s difficulties. These included lower social and economic standing, less positive maternal care, parental stress or mothers’ mental health problems, and being a boy. Care outside the home had small effects overall. Children who spent more time in group care, mostly nursery care, were more likely to have behavior difficulties, especially hyperactivity (being overly active and having trouble staying still). Because the study identified links, it does not show that childcare caused these difficulties. The authors suggest that support should strengthen families and improve care at home. Children’s home life mattered most, while more time in group care was linked to some behavior difficulties.

Abstract

BACKGROUND: Over the past few decades there has been a dramatic increase in maternal employment and, as a result, an increase in the use of non-maternal childcare in the early years. The purpose of this longitudinal study was to examine, in a large representative English sample, the influence of different forms of childcare on children's behavioural and emotional development around the age of school entry. METHODS: A sample of 991 families, originally recruited when the children were 3 months old, was assessed around school entry age at 51 months. The main outcome variable was the children's emotional and behavioural functioning, measured by questionnaire completed by both mothers and teachers. A range of repeated assessments were carried out at different time points, including direct observation of the quality of maternal caregiving and observations of the quality of non-parental care, and amount of time spent in different forms of care. RESULTS: The strongest and most consistent influences on behaviour and emotional problems were derived from the home, including lower socio-demographic status, poorer maternal caregiving, parental stress/maternal mental health problems, as well as child gender (being a boy). Non-parental childcare had small effects on child outcome. One finding that did emerge was that children who spent more time in group care, mainly nursery care, were more likely to have behavioural problems, particularly hyperactivity. CONCLUSIONS: These findings suggest that interventions to enhance children's emotional and behavioural development might best focus on supporting families and augmenting the quality of care in the home.

Referenced In