Journal Article 5 Mentions
Beyond Black and White: Ethnicity and Land Reform in Namibia
Eduard Gargallo•2011
Low Citations · 17th Percentile
6 citations · Soil Science
Open Access

TLDR

Namibia shares land without prioritizing communities that lost it during colonial rule. This approach aims to unite the country, but leaves many communities feeling unfairly treated.

Summary

1 Study Aim

Eduard Gargallo examines how ethnicity (shared group identity) shapes land reform (government efforts to redistribute land) in Namibia. He asks why the government rejects claims to ancestral land and how that policy affects communities’ sense of fair treatment. The study asks why the government shares land this way and which communities feel overlooked.

2 Study Design

The article reviews land laws, government policies, and debates about land and community leadership. Gargallo draws on interviews with government officials, local authorities, politicians, and people involved in resettlement, alongside field visits and reported disputes. He examines both commercial farms redistributed by the state and communal lands, where Traditional Authorities (TAs, local community leadership bodies) have a role in land management. The study looks at land rules and real disputes to understand how they affect communities.

3 Findings

Gargallo finds that the government distributes land without prioritizing communities dispossessed during colonial rule, arguing that this supports nation-building and avoids competing historical claims. The policy can give land to people who were not dispossessed, while some local communities feel bypassed. He also describes disputes over land access and the recognition of TAs, including cases involving San, Herero, Nama, and Damara communities. The authors’ analysis links these tensions to both ethnic identity and political interests, including the ruling party’s influence. Gargallo concludes that ignoring ethnic concerns has not prevented conflict; he cites the need to address relations between communities. Sharing land without listening to local communities can leave people feeling excluded and fuel disputes.

Abstract

Par-delà le Noir et le Blanc : ethnicité et réforme agraire en Namibie Le processus de réforme agraire en Namibie s’est inscrit dans la politique officielle de « construction nationale » qui tente d’ignorer les tensions ethniques à l’œuvre dans le pays. Le gouvernement a ainsi rejeté les revendications sur certaines terres ancestrales formulées par les communautés qui en ont été dépossédées durant la période coloniale, tout en refusant d’accorder le statut d’« indigène » à quelque communauté namibienne que ce soit. Les terres de fermiers blancs sont par conséquent redistribuées à des bénéficiaires « africains » indépendamment de leur identité ethnique ou de leur histoire, et des lots peuvent ainsi être attribués à des gens qui n’ont jamais été privés de leurs terres. Cet article tente de comprendre les raisons d’une telle politique et de montrer en quoi elle suscite au sein de nombreuses communautés un sentiment d’injustice.

Referenced In