Journal Article 2 Mentions
Assessing the impact of space weather on the electric power grid based on insurance claims for industrial electrical equipment
C. J. Schrijver2014
R. DobbinsWilliam Murtagh
Top 5% · 95th Percentile
90 citations · Health, Toxicology and Mutagenesis
Open Access

TLDR

Days when the Earth's magnetic field is more active lead to more problems with electrical equipment in businesses, causing extra insurance claims and business interruptions.

Summary

1 Study Aim

The primary aim of this paper is to determine whether changes in the Earth's magnetic field, known as geomagnetic activity (disturbances caused by space weather), are linked to increased rates of insurance claims for damaged or malfunctioning electrical and electronic equipment in North American businesses. The authors also seek to estimate the broader economic impact of these space weather-related power quality issues. The study wants to find out if space weather makes electrical problems in businesses more common.

2 Study Design

The research uses a retrospective cohort exposure study, analyzing 11,242 insurance claims filed between 2000 and 2010 for electrical and electronic equipment failures in North America. The authors compare claim rates on days with high geomagnetic activity (measured by rapid changes in the Earth's magnetic field) to rates on nearby days with low activity, carefully matching dates to control for other factors like season or business trends. They also compare these insurance claim patterns to records of disturbances in the high-voltage power grid over the same period. The study compares business insurance claims on stormy space weather days to calm days to see if there is a difference.

3 Findings

The study reveals that insurance claims for electrical equipment failures are about 20% higher on the most geomagnetically active days (top 5%) and about 10% higher on the top third of active days, compared to quiet days. Claims specifically linked to electrical surges show a similar pattern to major power grid disturbances. The authors estimate that around 500 insurance claims per year in North America are related to space weather effects. They find no significant difference in claim rates between high and low geomagnetic latitudes. The study suggests that space weather can cause widespread, costly disruptions in business operations, and that the total economic impact may be several billion dollars annually, though more detailed studies are needed to confirm this. The research shows that more electrical problems happen in businesses when space weather is active, leading to extra costs and disruptions.

Abstract

Abstract Geomagnetically induced currents are known to induce disturbances in the electric power grid. Here we perform a statistical analysis of 11,242 insurance claims from 2000 through 2010 for equipment losses and related business interruptions in North American commercial organizations that are associated with damage to, or malfunction of, electrical and electronic equipment. We find that claim rates are elevated on days with elevated geomagnetic activity by approximately 20% for the top 5% and by about 10% for the top third of most active days ranked by daily maximum variability of the geomagnetic field. When focusing on the claims explicitly attributed to electrical surges (amounting to more than half the total sample), we find that the dependence of claim rates on geomagnetic activity mirrors that of major disturbances in the U.S. high‐voltage electric power grid. The claim statistics thus reveal that large‐scale geomagnetic variability couples into the low‐voltage power distribution network and that related power‐quality variations can cause malfunctions and failures in electrical and electronic devices that, in turn, lead to an estimated 500 claims per average year within North America. We discuss the possible magnitude of the full economic impact associated with quality variations in electrical power associated with space weather.

Referenced In