Popular Boards
Nicholas J. Strausfeld | Brain Behavior and Evolution | (1998)
Key Takeaways
Plain English Takeaway
By studying the brains of different invertebrates, this paper shows that insects and crustaceans are more closely related to each other than to other groups like centipedes and millipedes.
Study Aim
The main goal of this paper is to use features found in the brains of segmented invertebrates to figure out how different groups, such as insects, crustaceans, and myriapods (centipedes and millipedes), are related to each other. The author wants to see if brain structures can help clarify which groups are closely related and which are not.
Simply put: The study tries to find out which invertebrates are most closely related by comparing their brain structures.
Study Design
The research examines and compares conserved neural characters (brain features that stay the same across species) in a range of segmented invertebrates and some related groups. The author analyzes specific parts of the brain, like the optic lobes (areas that process vision) and olfactory pathways (areas that process smell), to reconstruct evolutionary relationships. The study uses these brain features as evidence to build a family tree of these animals.
Simply put: The study compares brain parts from different invertebrates to see how they are related.
Findings
The analysis reveals that insects and crustaceans share several unique brain features, especially in their optic lobes and mid-brain, suggesting they are sister groups (each other's closest relatives). The study also argues that the group called 'myriapods' (centipedes and millipedes) is not a natural group, as its members are not closely related. Some brain features, like deep optic neuropils (layers in the visual brain area) and optic chiasmata (crossing points for nerve fibers), appear similar in insects and crustaceans due to convergent evolution, not shared ancestry. The research also finds that the olfactory lobes (smell centers) in insects likely evolved later in their history. The findings are discussed in light of recent work on how arthropod nervous systems develop and what the fossil record shows.
Simply put: The study finds that insects and crustaceans are closely related, and some brain similarities are due to shared ancestry, while others evolved separately.
Abstract
Conserved neural characters identified in the brains of a variety of segmented invertebrates and outgroups have been used to reconstruct phylogenetic relationships. The analysis suggests that insects and crustaceans are sister groups and that the 'myriapods' are an artificial construct comprising unrelated chilopods and diplopods. Certain elements of the optic lobes and mid-brain support the notion that insects are more closely related to crustaceans than they are to any other arthropods. However, deep optic neuropils and optic chiasmata are homoplastic in insects and crustaceans. The organization of olfactory pathways suggests that insect olfactory lobes originated late, probably first appearing in orthopteroid or blattoid pterygotes. The present results are discussed with respect to recent studies on early development of arthropod nervous systems and the fossil record.
(1) This paper proposes that "insects and crustaceans are sister groups".
This doesn't mean cockroaches are similar (as foods) to lobsters, but there is some relation evolution-wise.
As the Credo summary highlights: insects and crustaceans are "more closely related to each other than to other groups like centipedes and millipedes".