Popular Boards

Olen M. Kew, Peter F. Wright, Vadim I. Agol | PubMed | (2004)

Key Takeaways

Abstract

Within the past 4 years, poliomyelitis outbreaks associated with circulating vaccine-derived polioviruses (cVDPVs) have occurred in Hispaniola (2000-01), the Philippines (2001), and Madagascar (2001-02). Retrospective studies have also detected the circulation of endemic cVDPV in Egypt (1988-93) and the likely localized spread of oral poliovirus vaccine (OPV)-derived virus in Belarus (1965-66). Gaps in OPV coverage and the previous eradication of the corresponding serotype of indigenous wild poliovirus were the critical risk factors for all cVDPV outbreaks. The cVDPV outbreaks were stopped by mass immunization campaigns using OPV. To increase sensitivity for detecting vaccine-derived polioviruses (VDPVs), in 2001 the Global Polio Laboratory Network implemented additional testing requirements for all poliovirus isolates under investigation. This approach quickly led to the recognition of the Philippines and Madagascar cVDPV outbreaks, but of no other current outbreaks. The potential risk of cVDPV emergence has increased dramatically in recent years as wild poliovirus circulation has ceased in most of the world. The risk appears highest for the type 2 OPV strain because of its greater tendency to spread to contacts. The emergence of cVDPVs underscores the critical importance of eliminating the last pockets of wild poliovirus circulation, maintaining universally high levels of polio vaccine coverage, stopping OPV use as soon as it is safely possible to do so, and continuing sensitive poliovirus surveillance into the foreseeable future. Particular attention must be given to areas where the risks for wild poliovirus circulation have been highest, and where the highest rates of polio vaccine coverage must be maintained to suppress cVDPV emergence.

Referenced In

Claim: 70% of polio cases today are caused by the polio vaccine.

Validity: True but misleading

That's why most of the polio today, 70% of the polio today is vaccine polio that came from the vaccines. So the regulators expressed a preference for dead virus vaccines.

-Joe Rogan Experience #1999 23:15

https://youtu.be/p6LJXPOv4SM?si=8007SL4KBaY5IFw1&t=1395

It does appear true that many if not most of the polio today is caused by the vaccine rather than wild cases. This paper outlines the impacts of so called vaccine-derived polioviruses (VDPV). But it also outlines the importance of continued vaccine usage to eliminate wild cases of polio. The high percentage of VDPV as discussed by the WHO is actually an indicator of the success of polio vaccines. Wild cases have been cut so dramatically that the proportion of VDPV becomes larger. According to the WHO:

Cases due to wild poliovirus have decreased by over 99% since 1988, from an estimated 350 000 cases in more than 125 endemic countries, to two endemic countries.

It is also noted in the paper that the oral vaccine is the primary culprit of VDPV. While it is less expensive and therefore a more accessible option to eliminate wild polio cases, there are options that present no risk of VDPV. The WHO has begun implementing new strategies to reduce the risk of VDPV in the future.

2